Tuesday, January 16, 2018

Confused Words: lay / lie

Confused Words:  lay / lie


Lay is a transitive verb that means to put something or someone into a reclining position.  Transitive verbs are always followed by a direct object.  Thus, lay must always be followed by a noun or pronoun that answers "whom" or "what" to it -- a receiver of its action.
Correct
        
        Since lay takes a direct object in this sentence  (clothes), it is the correct verb to use here.

Incorrect
        
        Since lay does not have a direct object in this sentence, it is not the correct verb to use here.

Lie is an intransitive verb that means to put oneself in a reclining position.
A verb is intransitive when it has no direct object.  Since lie is intransitive, it may never be followed by a direct object (a noun or pronoun that answers "whom" or "what" after an action verb).
Correct
        
Incorrect
        
        Since clothes  functions as the direct object in the above sentence, the verb lie is incorrect.  The correct verb to use is lay.

Tense of lie and lay

Using "I" as a subject, one can form the  tenses  for these two verbs  as follows:

        Present                       Simple past              Present participle           Past participle

    I   lay  (something)              I laid  (something)        I am laying (something)        I have laid (something)    I    lie                               I lay                           I am lying                           I have lain

As you can see, when  it forms its tenses, the verb lay works just like the verb pay:

  Present                       Simple past              Present participle           Past participle

I lay                                I laid                                I am laying                            I have laid
I pay                               I paid                              I am paying                           I have paid


However, the verb lie is very irregular. 
 In fact, what makes these two verbs especially tricky is that the past tense of lie looks exactly like the present tense of  lay.

  Present                       Simple past              Present participle           Past participle

  I lie                               I lay                           I am lying                         I have lain  
  I lay
 (something)            I laid (something)           I am laying (something)       I have laid (something)


    Example - lie, present tense
        

    Example - lie, past tense
        
This similarity between the two verbs causes much confusion in their use.

Remember:  Lie is intransitive and, therefore, is never followed by a direct object.
                       Lay is transitive and, therefore, is always followed by a direct object.

                                                           AND
                        The past tense of lie looks exactly like the present tense of lay.

No comments:

Post a Comment